Halloween is right around the corner, and Staten Island party hosts are ready to impress guests with festive and flavorful treats! Whether you're throwing a costume bash or an intimate family gathering, having the right snacks can make your event spooktacular. Here’s a list of the top Halloween treats guaranteed to wow guests at your next Staten Island party.
No Staten Island party is complete without a seasonal favorite: pumpkin spice donuts. Whether you make them from scratch or pick up a box from local bakeries like Royal Crown or Piece A Cake, these soft, cinnamon-spiced treats are a must. To add an extra level of fun, create a donut bar where guests can add their own toppings, such as powdered sugar, frosting, and Halloween sprinkles.
Candy apples are a classic, but skewers make them easier to eat. Slice apples, dip them in caramel, and serve on sticks with toppings like crushed nuts, candy corn, or mini marshmallows. This mess-free version is ideal for both kids and adults.
Another option is to slice the apples, place them onto parchment paper, and drizzle them with melted chocolate or caramel sauce. You can then add various toppings, such as chocolate chips, nuts, and sprinkles. Pick up fresh apples from nearby Staten Island orchards like the Decker Farm.
Give traditional deviled eggs a Halloween makeover by adding green food coloring to the filling. Place an olive slice on top to resemble an eyeball, and use a drizzle of hot sauce for “veins.” These creepy appetizers are guaranteed to be a hit, so be sure to make plenty!
Mummy hot dogs are a fun and filling addition to any Halloween party. Simply wrap hot dogs in crescent roll dough, leaving small gaps to make them look like mummies. Bake until golden brown, and use mustard or ketchup for "eyes." Pair them with Staten Island's favorite spicy mustard for extra zing!
Monster chicken sliders are a fun and flavorful twist on traditional sliders. Use breaded or grilled chicken tenders or nuggets on mini slider buns and dress them up to look like playful monsters. Use creative toppings like cherry tomatoes or olives for the “eyes,” pickles, onions, or jalapenos for the “tongues,” and slices of cheese cut into triangles for the “teeth.”
These mini dessert cups are easy to assemble and look adorable. Layer chocolate pudding, crushed cookies for “dirt,” and top with gummy worms. Add a cookie “tombstone” for extra effect by writing "RIP" in frosting.
Transform your beverage station into a cauldron of magic! A green or red “witch’s brew” punch, made with soda, fruit juices, and gummy worms, adds a creepy touch. Use dry ice to create fog for a dramatic effect as guests pour their drinks. Other fun Halloween-themed drinks include pumpkin margaritas, poison apple cocktails, and bloody marys.
Popcorn balls are simple to make and can be dressed up for Halloween by adding candy pieces and white chocolate drizzle. Shape them into ghostly figures, or wrap them individually for party favors. Visit a Staten Island candy shop like Egger’s Ice Cream Parlor to find the best candy mix-ins.
Brownies are always a hit, and a spider web design adds a spooky twist. Drizzle white frosting in a spiral pattern over chocolate brownies, then use a toothpick to draw out lines to form the web. Add a small plastic spider on top for a finishing touch.
Hosting a Halloween party in Staten Island? These treats will help you create an unforgettable event with flavors and fun that everyone will love. So, get creative, add a bit of Halloween magic, and make your party the talk of Staten Island! Don’t forget that La Rosa Chicken and Grill offers catering services that are perfect for events like Halloween! Between grilled and crispy chicken, freshly prepared sides, and buttery cornbread, you can feed a crowd without having to lift a finger!
Happy Halloween! 🎃